Case #1: Bird Honking

Judgey Court is now in session, the honorable Judgey Bear presiding.

Our first case involves a man in a truck who honked his horn at a grouping of pigeons on the road. The defendant was driving along Kimball Ave. on Tuesday morning, at approximately 8:45 am. He proceeded, northbound, through the intersection at Wilson Ave, and approached a grouping of pigeons in the middle of the road. Upon his approach, the defendant honked at said pigeons and proceeded down the road.

PROSECUTION: Your Honor, a car or truck's horn is meant to portend danger or caution. It should be employed in emergency situations only, when a driver could fend off a collision by warning another driver. Drivers should exercise discipline and restraint when it comes to the horn. Horns should not serve as punitive commentary or wildlife scattering tactics. The city of Chicago is a crowded, bustling place, especially during the morning and evening commute. If everyone were permitted to honk at birds, then what would be next? Squirrels, surely. Stray cats? Of course. Billowing plastic bags that wander across your path? Soon we'd have a city full of Honkers, exponentially increasing the noise pollution on the streets. Moreover, overuse of horns desensitizes the citizens of our city to its noise. If horn usage runs unchecked, then when someone uses a horn as a legitimate warning, chances increase that the intended audience will disregard its sound.

DEFENSE: Your Honor, the defendant WAS trying to avoid an imminent collision--with the pigeons. By honking, he was able to alert the birds to his approaching vehicle and give them sufficient time to evacuate. Why should birds be overlooked when it comes to road safety? The defendant was merely showing the same consideration toward a fellow living animal as the horn's design intends: warn someone else of impending danger.

JUDGEY BEAR: Pigeons aren't exactly an endangered species around here, are they Pickup Guy?

PG: No, sir.

JUDGEY BEAR: Did you slow down as you approached these pigeons?

PG: No, sir.

JUDGEY BEAR: If you truly wish to ensure pigeons have adequate time to fly away from your approaching vehicle, you could slow down and NOT honk. Even that is not necessary. You don't see a lot of pigeon carcasses around these days. They seem to have evolved the ability to fly out of the way of your car. Do you understand?

PG: Yes, Your Honor.

JUDGEY BEAR: I find the defendant guilty. (Bad driver! GRAWR!!) I sentence you to two years of revoked horn privileges. See the bailiff about removing the horn from your car.

Next Case: Getting Sick in Public